Paper Tiger Reaction – James Gray Keeps On

Our Paul Gratton takes a look at Paper Tiger, now in limited release and expanding through North America this November & December.

About: In 1986 New York, a naive engineer accepts a seemingly lucrative business proposition from his brother, a former cop. But when one of them witnesses something he wasn’t meant to see, the siblings find themselves pulled into a dangerous confrontation with the newly emerging Russian mafia. Stars Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson & Miles Teller.



Reaction: James Gray makes compelling indie films that usually feature great performances. He has touched on a variety of genres over the years, but his most memorable films have been about families in peril. Films such as The Yards and Little Odessa are perfect examples of this type of tightly written, modestly budgeted domestic thriller. Paper Tiger falls squarely within this genre. Miles Teller plays a decent middle class Jewish engineer named Gary Pearl in the 1980s in Queens. He goes from contract to contract, but times are tough, especially with two sons to support. Along comes his slick, slightly seedy brother Irwin (one of Adam Driver’s best performances so far) who claims that some new entrepreneurs are planning to develop the local waterfront, and that some fast easy money can be made, as the massive project will require environmental and pollution evaluations, an area Gary specializes in. What soon becomes clear is that these entrepreneurs are the Russian mafia, and when Tiles runs afoul of them (the last thing they really wanted was an honest approach to their pollution plans), while his two sons are waiting in the car, he crosses into the worst world he could imagine: putting his family in jeopardy. In case he missed the memo, the Russians break into his house at night and send him pictures of his two sons sleeping. Meanwhile his loving but tough housewife is dealing with her own challenges of a health nature, that may also result in the family being in jeopardy on a different front. Scarlett Johansson gives one of the most forceful performances of her career, and deserves an Oscar nomination for this. She commits an act of betrayal that may well exacerbate the conflict that is growing between the two parties. Uncle Irwin decides to settle things once and for all, which sets up a tense and exciting climax. The plotting gets a little wobbly at times but the performances are so good that all should be forgiven by discerning filmgoers. This is especially true given that this type of film, the mid-range adult-oriented independent drama, is a dying species in today’s marketplace. It too is a paper tiger, a delicate artistic construct that is on borrowed ground.


Jason Whyte | Get Reel Movies

Leave a Reply