Bitter Christmas Reaction – Holiday Cheer Thru Almodovar

Both Jason & Paul take another look at the somewhat disappointing Bitter Christmas, which screened back at this year’s Toronto International Film Festival.

About: Bitter Christmas tells two alternating stories, one starring Elsa, an advertising director, in 2004, during a long weekend in December. The second takes place in 2026 and stars Raúl, a screenwriter and director who is writing a script that we soon discover is the story of Elsa, her boyfriend Bonifacio, and her friends Patricia and Natalia. Mixed with fiction, Elsa is, in a way, Raúl’s alter ego, who, like him, resorts to autofiction as a solution to a long period of creative drought. He looks inside himself, and he can’t help but also look at the people who make up his most intimate universe: his partner and his assistant. The film narrates the close relationship between reality and fiction, between inspiration and life, exploring the limits of autofiction and stories within stories.



Paul’s Reaction: Pedro Almodovar has become a pompous bore as a filmmaker. Once the most exciting filmmaking voice to emerge from the post-fascist era in Spain, his proud queer voice, his focus on melodramatic Douglas Sirkian-female focused storylines, his brilliant use of colour on screen, the way he framed his protagonists, everything made for the most stylistically distinct and complex filmography of the last forty years. Films like Labyrinth of Passion and Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown were , quite frankly, art house masterpieces. But with success comes complacency. And Almodovar’s recent films have all been examples of auto-fiction, his films all vaguely concerned with himself, his medical problems, his ageing, his lack of creative inspiration, his failed relationships, etc.. etc… no one cares about the trials and tribulations of an immensely successful filmmaker long past his prime. Looking at one’s belly-button is not a very good source of inspiration for a filmmaker. In Bitter Christmas, the framing is classic Almodovorian, as a screenwriter in 2025 , Raoul, takes us into his latest work, as he flashes back to a storyline set in 2004, in which Elsa is suffering from creative bloc. Her mother has recently died and she suffers from migraines. Meanwhile her creative career as a filmmaker has hit a roadblock. She escapes for a seaside holiday with a friend, and it soon becomes apparent that she is cribbing from her friends’ personal lives in order to come up with material for her new screenplay. What a betrayal! The nature of inspiration and the process of creativity as subject-matter is beaten to a pulp in this film. Few will care. Meanwhile, back in 2025, the only exciting scene in the movie is when Raoul’s long-term assistant who has quit on relatively good terms, decides to lace into him as a creatively-blocked has-been talent living on his past glories. The scene crackles with energy, something sorely lacking from the rest of this slow, pretentious bore. Pedro, retire already, or wait until you have a real story to tell, one that is not about you.


" "

Jason’s Reaction: A very quick note on this one, as I really admired what Paul wrote about it. Like him, I found this new Almodóvar film a little bit tiring. I remember both Paul and me sitting through a weary morning press screening at TIFF this year, discussing the film afterward and trying to figure out what had just happened.

Paul already commented more on the story, so this is just a few more of my thoughts from TIFF. While I admire a lot of the look and feel of his latest work, I was ultimately underwhelmed by the overall presentation. This somber story of an older man looking back at his latest creative work and going back in time to rediscover his creative self feels like something that would only appeal to devoted Almodóvar fans who still get excited when his name randomly pops up in a trailer before an art house screening.

It’s not that I intensely disliked his latest movie, but I forgot about it pretty quickly after leaving the screening and moving on to the next one. That’s definitely not a feeling I’ve had with his previous works. Still, if you like Pedro and his work and want to see it, seek it out if it comes to a cinema near you!


Jason Whyte | Get Reel Movies

Leave a Reply